David Chiu ’24

---

Although universities are making a nationwide push towards a test-optional or even a test-blind application process, pressure to achieve stellar standardized testing scores persists, especially for highly selective colleges. And this brings about the question: should students take the SAT or the ACT? 

Oftentimes, you hear recommendations like “If you are good at science, take the ACT.” However, a student’s compatibility with a certain test should be based on concrete experience rather than on a hunch—taking both tests will help bring about a comprehensive understanding of both exams and in turn help you develop a valid preference. 

However, it  makes sense to look at some of the key differences between the SAT and the ACT. The most glaring difference is the time allotted per question—the SAT allows more time per question compared to the ACT for every question. Those who tend to struggle with time management might find the reading and math sections of the ACT especially difficult. And, yes, the ACT introduces a different section: science. In this section, students must analyze scientific data and decipher charts and graphs quickly in order to meet the challenging time constraints. 

Like many students, I struggled with this dilemma when first faced with the standardized testing process. Against reason, I arbitrarily developed a slight preference for the SAT without any particular cause. Consequently, I failed to improve my score while remaining staunchly attached to solely taking the SAT. Not until spring junior year did I conceive of trying the ACT. My reasoning for holding off for so long was ludicrous. It was my distaste I had developed years before after taking a mock ACT exam. Nevertheless, I reluctantly but briefly prepared for a spring ACT. Even though I disliked the idea of scientific passages, I found more success with the ACT than I did with the SAT. Why? I’m not sure, but I am thankful that my pigheadedness did not restrict me from fulfilling my potential with standardized testing. 

If faced with this decision, take a step back and consider that you might be able to gel more easily with one test rather than the other. You will likely develop a fervent disposition for one over the other—and that it is okay. But don’t remain so attached to one choice when you haven’t tried the other. Try both to see which one is better for you.